User talk:Dragomir7

History

Hi,

I was wondering what if for the history pages, what if we combined it into the pages like:

• 2021
• 2023
• 2025

instead of transclude to the main page, with the main history page becoming chronological order?

— Preceding unsigned comment added by Supernutorcrazy, 03:46, 7 March 2025 (UTC)

@Supernutorcrazy: I think that would be too much work, because most services' routes don't actually change that much across years so if you want to take snapshots every year there will be a LOT of duplication for services. The way the pages log the changes to each service right now is fine, if only a bit too colourful for my liking (I liked the old text-only version better, with at most some bus op logos).

If you intend to log route changes, the most that you could do would be to follow what landtransportguru has on their page, but as a standalone article; combining it into each year article would make it way too cluttered; be mindful that this wiki doesn't only cater to buses or transport, after all. At most just put a link in the year article.

Just my two cents. (Also you might want to consider signing your comments with four tildes "~".) Dragomir7 (talk) 12:00, 7 March 2025 (+08)

@Dragomir7 I not saying to log snapshot for every year, but like what you pointed out like their page, while keeping the old history page for a consolidate of defunct service (reduce pages), with the rest into the individual page (no transclusion).

The difference here in sgWiki yearly page provide a chronological order, and also can merged with other pages (for example, MRT/LRT, places of attractions etc.) because is sgWiki (singapore wiki) not bus wiki.

Supernutorcrazy (talk) 12:08, 7 March 2025 (+08)